We've just come to the end of another series of Popmaster TV. It only feels like yesterday that the first series began but it's getting on for 3 years now. What did I make of this latest series?
Well one of the differences this time is I most likely watched most of the episodes on catch up this time round whereas previously I'd made more of an effort to watch it live. I watched every episode but somehow felt less engaged this time round. Whilst I applied to the first 2 series and failed to get on, I didn't bother applying this time round though did consider it.
There is something that's occurred to me, are the earlier rounds too specialised or is Popmaster itself a specialist area of music knowledge that we don't realise?
I say this because there are contestants who have been on Champions League on the radio version who have gone out early on the TV version. As a former Champions League contestant myself I do question whether I would be one of those were I to get on.
I like the links round and do get the majority of questions correct. I find the way questions link together quite interesting. My only complaint is lack of consistency, I recall in one episode one contestant had quite simple questions such as what instrument Mick Fleetwood plays then the next contestant got questions about Taylor Swift and One Direction which is something most people over 35 will struggle with which is most contestants.
I feel like if I was to draw the Taylor Swift and One Direction questions in that it would be an early bath for me. I'm not bad at the intros, middles and ends round but the contestants can be very quick and I could easily see myself scoring zero in that round.
In the grand final I kept a worst case scenario score in the first 2 rounds. My worst links score from a set of questions was 9 and there were 2 songs in the intros, middles and ends round where I shouted out the answer before any contestant buzzed and both would have bagged me 5 points, so 19 points which would have comfortably seen me through to the next round.
Video Gaga has changed this series and for the better in my opinion. My previous gripe was the lack of consistency, one contestant would get a still from an iconic video whilst another would get a video from 2020 that nobody under 25 has seen. Now the contestant can buzz in with an answer to a question and then pick a category for the video they get.
However the Video Gaga round wasn't so good in the grand final. 3 of the 4 sets of questions were far too modern and one set was a video by Leon Bridges who I've never heard of before. He's never had a Top 40 hit either and this brought back memories of the new Jack Savoretti song being a Popmaster question in the Radio 2 days which you fortunately don't get on Greatest Hits Radio.
The Mixtape round often has at least one artist I've never heard of or couldn't name a record by, but at least the contestant can try to avoid that artist when pressing the button. The years round is what it is and no complaints really aside from when the year is too modern.
I've already ranted about It's Only Words carrying too many points so I won't go there again. What I will say is that if I was on the show I would have possibly made it to this point, but there's no way I would have scored enough points on this round to make it to the final.
The eye opener for the regular Popmaster round is that I don't think any contestant scored a full house this series. Most of the contestants got nowhere near and there was one contestant who scored zero. This brings me back to my original point, does regular Popmaster only cover an element of ones music knowledge or are the earlier rounds too specialist? Like I said we've had contestants who have scored full houses on the radio get eliminated early and contestants who have clocked up lots of points in the earlier rounds but struggled with the final.
It's already been confirmed there will be a 4th series but will there be a 5th?
I'm not so sure. From where I've looked on the internet there seems to be very little discussion about it. When I watched the grand final I could count the number of tweets on the hashtag on my hands. I've not found any articles about it. I feel the excitement of Popmaster making it to TV has faded away. I'll continue to watch until they pull the plug but I do think it's days are numbered.